Real Trolley Problems

All games

Real Trolley Problems

Playable

17 real choices from history. Would you pull the lever?

Real Trolley Problems is a free trolley problem game built on true stories. Instead of a made-up trolley and five people on the tracks, each round puts you in the place of someone who really had to choose: an officer watching a missile alert, a ship's helmsman, a doctor in a flooded hospital, an engineer the night before a launch.

You read what they knew at the time, then pick one of two tracks before the clock runs out. After you pull the lever, the case file opens: what really happened, what they chose and what it cost them. At the end you see in how many cases you chose like history.

The original trolley problem is a thought experiment. These were not. If you like testing your own judgment, try How Bad Is It or Eye Duel, and see how your mind works in Mind Lab.

How to play

Read the situation. You only know what the real person knew at that moment.

Choose one of the two tracks before the timer runs out. Doing nothing is also a choice.

See what really happened, then move to the next case. At the end, compare your choices with history and copy your result.

What makes it different

17 documented moral dilemmas, including Stanislav Petrov, Vasily Arkhipov, Hugh Thompson, Chiune Sugihara, Fukushima and Challenger

A sober railway-switch interface, no cartoons

See whether you chose like the people who were there

What is the trolley problem?

The trolley problem was introduced by philosopher Philippa Foot in 1967 and later developed by Judith Jarvis Thomson. A runaway trolley is heading toward five people. You can pull a lever to send it onto a side track where it will kill one person. Do you act, or let it happen?

The puzzle asks whether causing harm is worse than allowing it, and whether numbers alone decide what is right. Real trolley problems add what the thought experiment leaves out: uncertainty, time pressure, orders, and consequences for the person who chooses.

Real trolley problems in history

Every case in the game is a documented event. In 1983 Stanislav Petrov judged a nuclear launch alert to be a false alarm. In 1962 Vasily Arkhipov refused to approve a nuclear torpedo during the Cuban Missile Crisis. In 1940 Chiune Sugihara wrote visas against orders. Other cases include hospital triage during Hurricane Katrina, the decision to launch Challenger, the Norwegian heavy water sabotage and the shipwreck case R v Dudley and Stephens.

Some of these people were later celebrated, some were punished, and some were never thanked. The game does not tell you which choice was right. It only shows you what they chose.

FAQ

What are real trolley problems?

They are real situations where someone had to choose between two harmful outcomes, like the classic trolley problem but with real lives, limited information and time pressure.

Are the stories in the game true?

Yes. Every case is based on a documented historical event, with the date, place and the people involved.

Is there a right answer?

No. The game compares your choice with what really happened, not with what was morally correct.

Is it free and does it work on mobile?

Yes. Play free in your browser without an account, by tapping on a phone or clicking on a computer.

Some cases involve real deaths. Summaries are simplified for the game.

Real Trolley Problems game artwork