Stay or Switch?

All games

Stay or Switch?

Playable

Three doors. One car. Would you switch?

Stay or Switch? is a free interactive Monty Hall problem simulator. One of three doors hides a car; the other two hide goats. Choose a door, watch the host reveal a goat behind another door, then decide whether to keep your first choice or switch to the remaining closed door.

Play five rounds yourself before exploring the same problem with 100 doors. Then run a simulation of 10 to 100,000 trials and compare two strategies: always stay and always switch. The live bars show how the results settle toward the expected probabilities as the number of trials grows.

Part of our collection of interactive learning games. If you enjoy finding out where intuition goes wrong, try the behavioral experiments in Mind Lab or the hidden-choice twists in Gut Check.

How to play

Pick one of the three doors. After the host opens a different door to reveal a goat, choose Stay or Switch. Play all five rounds to see your results and share them with a friend.

Try the 100-door bonus round, where the host opens 98 goat doors. Continue to the simulator, select a trial count and press Run to compare the two strategies.

The Monty Hall problem explained

Under the classic rules, the host knows where the car is, always opens an unchosen door containing a goat and always offers you the chance to switch. Your first pick has a 1 in 3 chance of being the car. Switching wins whenever that first pick was wrong β€” which happens 2 times out of 3.

That makes the expected win rate 33.3% for staying and 66.7% for switching. Two closed doors do not make the odds 50/50: the host's reveal is informed, not random. A short run can still favor staying by chance, so use the larger simulations to see the long-run difference.

Why try the Monty Hall problem with 100 doors?

With 100 doors, your first choice has only a 1% chance of hiding the car. The host then opens 98 unchosen goat doors, leaving your door and one alternative. Staying wins 1% of the time; switching wins 99%. The larger version makes the same probability argument easier to see.

FAQ

What is a Monty Hall simulator?

It repeats the three-door probability puzzle so you can compare staying with your original door against switching after an informed host reveals a goat. Stay or Switch? includes five playable rounds, a 100-door example and simulations of up to 100,000 trials.

Should you stay or switch in the Monty Hall problem?

Under the classic rules, switching wins with probability 2/3, while staying wins with probability 1/3. Switching is the better long-run strategy, but it does not guarantee a win in any individual round.

Why isn't the Monty Hall problem 50/50?

The host knows where the car is and deliberately reveals a goat behind an unchosen door. Your original door retains its 1/3 chance; the remaining alternative has a 2/3 chance. If the host follows different rules, those probabilities may change.

Can I run a Monty Hall simulation online for free?

Yes. Stay or Switch? runs in your browser without a download or account. Choose 10, 100, 1,000, 10,000 or 100,000 trials and compare the two win rates.

Stay or Switch? game artwork